What Should You Do If Your Dog Tears an ACL?

Poor Sophy

If you are unlucky (like me), and your dog tears its anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) be forewarned; you are in for a bumpy ride.  I love my dogs.  They are healthy, happy and very active labs.  But 18 months ago, when my Sophy tore her ACL I was just so unsure of what to do for her.  So I did my research.  Read one internet site and they tell you you can “cure it” by rest and confinement.  Read another site and they say you should immediately take your dog  in for surgery to minimize arthritis later in life.  Well I made my decision for Sophy and was convinced it was the proper one.

Fast forward 12 months and my other dog Chester tore his ACL in a “sports injury”.  Having already gone through this once with Sophy, I did the research all over again.  This time I made the mistake of telling someone of my decision and they verbally attacked me.  They said “how can you play God with the life of your dog”.  At first I was horrified and felt ashamed; then I just got angry! Who was she to judge me.  But it was because of that one comment that I started the Raising Healthy Dogs site.

And I have one crucial piece of news for you….we will all make mistakes.  Just like our parents made mistakes raising us, we will make mistakes raising our dogs.  All we can do is make decisions for their welfare based on imperfect and often biased information and the resources we have available to us.  So if you dog tears an ACL, do your research, speak with your vet and a surgeon if necessary and shut out all the negative noise.  Following is an overview of the problem and various treatment options. It was written by a vet and reviewed by a surgeon.  For anyone interested, I chose TPLO for both dogs.  If anyone want so talk about the experience or has questions, let me know.  I am more than happy to share my experiences and tips for recovery.

Frances

To understand what happens when a dog ruptures his cruciate ligament, and how it can be treated, we need to learn a little about the anatomy of the knee joint.

Your dog has two cruciate ligaments in his knee. They criss cross the space between the femur and the tibia (hence their name), and prevent these bones moving forwards and backwards against each other. Between the two bones lie two little crescents of cartilage called menisci (singular is meniscus). These act as shock absorbers when your dog walks and runs, and protect the cartilage at the end of the two bones.

Rupture of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is by far the most common injury that can occur to a dog’s knee. There are two common scenarios that occur when this ligament ruptures. Firstly, a young active dog hurts his knee while he’s running around playing games or chasing birds. Secondly, an elderly dog with weakened ligaments or a degree of arthritis may sustain the same injury because  the ligament has degenerated with age. In both cases, there is a sudden onset of lameness, and the leg is so painful that they can’t put their foot down.

If your dog has ruptured his cruciate ligament, you have several treatment options to choose from. In most cases, surgery is necessary to prevent excess movement in the joint, which will inevitably lead to arthritis.   Surgery also allows your veterinarian to tidy up any ragged edges to the menisci, which can cause ongoing discomfort.

Let’s have a closer look at the different ways of treating a cruciate rupture in your dog.

Non Surgical Treatment

If your dog is small, you may choose to do nothing. When the acute pain resolves, little dogs may recover enough to be comfortable with being given pain relieving anti-inflammatory medication when required. Natural joint support products such as glucosamine and green lipped muscle extract can also help. It can take over 4 months before they recover to this level. This treatment option is really only appropriate for dogs under 30lbs, as heavier animals put too much stress on their knees. Keep in mind also that long term use of anti-inflammatory drugs can have effects on your dog’s stomach and kidneys.

Prolotherapy can be useful in helping to manage a cruciate rupture if surgery isn’t an option. This procedure involves injection of a solution into the knee which causes scarring around the joint. This scarring helps to stabilize the joint and reduce excess movement. It’s a controversial procedure; it can have good results, but it can also lead to complications such as excessive inflammation. To get the best outcome from this procedure, it should be done by an orthopedic specialist.

If your budget allows it, surgery is still the best option for all cases of cruciate rupture in dogs.

Extracapsular Repair

“Extracapsular” means outside the joint capsule, so this method of repair doesn’t involve any implants or modifications to the inside of the knee joint.

After the  joint has been opened, and any damaged bone, ligament and meniscus have been removed, a strong suture is placed on the outside of the knee to take the place of the torn ligament. The suture is passed behind the fabella, a small bone that sits right at the back of the knee near the bottom of the femur, and then through a hole drilled through the front of the tibia. It is tied sufficiently tightly to stabilize the knee, while still allowing a normal range of movement.

Post-operative care involves 8 weeks of rest, then a gradual increase in exercise. Over time, scar tissue will develop around the knee joint, and this will reduce excess movement. The suture itself often breaks within 12 months after the procedure, but by then the knee should be held stable by its own tissues.

This procedure is quick, and inexpensive when compared to the more invasive methods of repair. It can work well in small dogs, and is particularly useful in puppies, where you don’t want to make changes to the bones themselves while they are still growing.

Tightrope Procedure.

This is another extracapsular method of repair, but in this case, a hole is drilled through the bottom of the femur, and the top of the tibia. A double band of strong Fiber Tape is passed through these holes and down the outside of the joint, and serves to replace the ruptured cruciate ligament.

This procedure is relatively easy to perform, and is also more affordable than the repairs that involve cutting and manipulating the tibia. It has been shown to be effective in treating cruciate rupture in most sizes of dogs, however many veterinarians prefer to restrict its use to dogs that weigh under 70lbs.

Tibial Plateau Leveling Osteotomy (TPLO)

TPLO is the most commonly recommended method of repairing a ruptured cruciate ligament in dogs. It relies on cutting and rotating the tibia in such a way that the dog’s own weight bearing stabilizes his joint. After the tibia is cut and moved, a metal plate is screwed to the tibia to keep it in its new position.

This is a very complex procedure, and should only be undertaken by veterinarians who have had special training in how to do it correctly. It is expensive, costing several thousand dollars. There are several reasons for this:

It should only be performed by an orthopedic specialist.

  • Multiple x-rays are necessary to make sure the cut in the bone is done in the right place.
  • The metal screws and plate are expensive.

This procedure is suitable for dogs of all sizes. It is particularly appropriate for larger dogs over 50lbs, and for athletic dogs such as those involved in agility competition. It’s not the best choice for dogs whose bones haven’t finished growing, because the physical changes to the tibia can lead to their own set of problems as the bones continue to grow.

As with other methods of cruciate repair, exercise must be restricted for 8 weeks after surgery, and most dogs return to full function after 3-4 months.

Tibial Tuberosity Advancement (TTA)

 

This is another repair method that relies on biomechanics to stabilize the knee joint. The idea behind this relatively new procedure is that if the top of the tibia and the patellar ligament (the ligament from the kneecap to the front of the tibia) are realigned at 90 degrees to each other, the joint will be stable when the dog walks.

Again, the tibia is cut, but this time the front of the tibia where the patellar ligament actually attaches is removed, and moved forward. It is held in position by metal implants, and the gap between the front of the tibia and the rest of the bone is filled by a bone graft.

Although it doesn’t sound like it, the TTA procedure is less invasive, and has similar results to the TPLO surgery. It too is expensive, because of the metal implants and because it must be done by a board certified specialist. Dogs that have had TTA surgery often appear to recover quicker than those with a TPLO, however by 6 months post-operatively, both procedures have a similar outcome.

The TTA is suitable for all dogs, and which procedure your dog undergoes may just depend on your orthopedic specialist’s proficiency at each. You’ll find that some specialists prefer to perform a TTA, while others feel that they get better results from the TPLO procedure.

Post Operative Care

Your orthopedic surgeon will prescribe pain relief to keep your dog comfortable and will give you specific advice on how to care for him after his operation.

After surgery to repair a ruptured cruciate ligament, the most important thing you can do for your dog is to rest him. Ideally, keep him crated and only take him out on a leash to go to the toilet.

Most dogs feel quite well long before their bone has healed, and this is when many owners start to take them for walks or otherwise increase their activity. This can cause breakdown of the surgery, so it is vital that you follow your vet’s directions very carefully.

Post-operative physical therapy can be beneficial to dogs after this type of surgery. This can take the form of massage, hydrotherapy, and gently moving the leg through its range of motion. The results are reduced swelling and inflammation, and increased healing, which will improve your dog’s demeanor and attitude.

Conclusion

A ruptured cruciate ligament is a severe injury, that can have long term effects on your dog’s well-being. Fortunately, it can be treated and in most cases, this results in a return to normal function.

There are two main factors which influence which treatment option is right for your dog.

  • Finances. Some procedures are more expensive than others, and your family budget will have a big impact on how your dog’s knee is repaired.
  • Your dog’s age and size. Some procedures are not appropriate for young dogs, and others are less likely to be successful in large breeds.
  • A third factor is your orthopedic specialist’s preference, and their experience with each of the procedures.

Take the time to discuss your options with your dog’s surgeon, and together you will decide on how to treat your dog so that he again can enjoy going for a walk or playing with you in the park.


171 Responses to “What Should You Do If Your Dog Tears an ACL?”

  1. Julia says:

    Thanks Frances, it really means a lot!
    We’ve been doing our best to keep him “entertained.”
    He’s really very intelligent and observant. He gets bored easily.
    As of right now he’s actually chewing at my textbook because he got bored with his toy.
    My family is considering giving him away to someone guaranteed to get him the surgery. I hope it doesn’t come down to that, but I think that’s a better alternative than having to euthanize him if things get bad so. We’re kind of ‘stuck between a rock and a hard place’

  2. Frances says:

    Hi Julia I am so sorry about your pup. If you cannot do surgery try conservative management. I thought my big girl needed surgery and I tried conservative management instead. Well 18 months later she is still going strong and never had the surgery for that leg.

  3. Julia says:

    My family and I have an 8 month year old Labrador retriever.
    He was doing fine- we worked him out regularly- long walks to the creek and swimming during the summer months, took him his first times out with us pheasant hunting (he mainly just walked alongside is and was just happy to be with is)–he was a solid, muscular little boy.
    He had just undergone his neutering procedure when we started to notice him limping. His leg muscle was tight and the veterinarian that had performed the surgery prescribed anti-inflamatories.
    He went for x-Rays.
    We got the results last week. He had a ruptured ACL apparently due to a traumatic incident.
    Recently, when he was let outside my mom left him unattended. She came back out and he was standing there, turned his head, and cried terribly–he then laid down. She couldn’t get him to stand up after.
    We’re pretty sure he has messed up his other leg. He’s been “hobbling” around on three legs now.
    He’s been on Glucosamine and resting except for while we are home. He continually jumps around, uses his hind legs to scratch at his body, tries to run to us after we let him out of his cage when we return home.. Etc.
    To help alleviate pain while he is sore we put a heating pad on his behind.
    We don’t know what to do now. His quality of life seems ruined forever to us because of this injury, Afterall, he is just a pup.
    We were told he will never be able to hunt, go on long excursions, etc. He will never be the same. The only activity we will be able to let him continue to enjoy occasionally will be a swim.
    Any advice is welcome. My parents, brother, and I are all heartbroken, angry/upset, and depressed. This waiting game has only just begun but we’re not sure what other actions we can take.
    The breeder we bought him from has not been present. She has recently actually hasn’t said anything to us since we took him to her specialist.
    We are not even completely sure he can just be a “house dog.” And even then he’ll be restricted.
    Help, advice, please.
    We are not considering surgery due to financial circumstances.

  4. Mick says:

    I have a adorable 7 years 4 months old dogue de bordeaux who I think may have damaged her cruciate she is currently on pain relife I believe it’s called rimadyl 100 mg .She is a little stiff on a morning and dose not put her full weight on intermittent sometimes looks fine sometimes limps.The problem I have is she has heart condition that requires medication I was told 2.5 years ago that she wouldn’t last 5 months as worst case they had had but she is fighting on relatively good odd off day due to meds but happy dog.I would do anything to give her healthy happy life but I understand that knocking her out to x ray or operate she is unlikely to come through due to heart problem at wits end as dont know what to do for the best do I chance x ray or give her longer on pain relife hopeing she improves I’m so unsure what to do my vet has gave a months course of pain relife to see how it goes after this I will be left with a predicament I know she couldn’t manage without pain relife at minute but x ray could finish her off just bit of advice on what people think I know it’s expensive but would go without to help her just want to get it right thanks.

  5. […] What Should You Do If Your Dog Tears an ACL? | Raising … – If you are unlucky (like me), and your dog tears its anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) be forewarned; you are in for a bumpy ride. I love my dogs…. […]

  6. Barbara says:

    October 7, 2014

    Missy,

    Both my 7 and 8 year old cocker spaniels have had TTAs at their
    current age and have gotten along very well. The surgery is a
    little expensive, but my dogs are worth it! My advise is to find
    another vet. Plus it never hurts to get a 2nd opinion anyway.
    For now, the vet’s office should have a sling/leash that you can put
    around your dogs belly to help hold him up when you take him out.
    They give these to you after the TTA to help support them
    temporarily while healing after surgery when you take them outside.

  7. nadinr says:

    I have a 11 year old border collie that tore acl vet says no to surgery because strength in rear couldn’t handle. What is there out there to help him he is very stubborn.

  8. […] What Should You Do If Your Dog Tears an ACL? | Raising … – If you are unlucky (like me), and your dog tears its anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) be forewarned; you are in for a bumpy ride. I love my dogs…. […]

  9. […] What Should You Do If Your Dog Tears an ACL? | Raising … […]

  10. Kimberly says:

    My dog, Willy, tore his ACL about a month and I got him the A-Trac brace from Wound Wear. At first I had some issues with rubbing of the skin on his uninjured leg by the velcro straps but resolved it by covering it with a towel. Overall the brace has been wonderful and Willy has tolerated wearing the brace very well! I even think he enjoys it ;)

  11. […] What Should You Do If Your Dog Tears an ACL? | Raising … – If you are unlucky (like me), and your dog tears its anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) be forewarned; you are in for a bumpy ride. I love my dogs…. […]

  12. […] What Should You Do If Your Dog Tears an ACL? | Raising … – If you are unlucky (like me), and your dog tears its anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) be forewarned; you are in for a bumpy ride. I love my dogs…. […]

  13. Missy says:

    I asked about wrapping too…my vet said NO. you have no way of knowing if you are cutting off circulation, esp to the paw.

  14. Missy says:

    I am having UCLCERS over this. my 9 1/2 year old cocker, had just gotten a clean bill of health after 4 cancer surgeries. we were really enjoying this summer. he so loved to hike. he chased a squirrel, zigzaged, got his leg caught in a flower bed border and next thing I knew he was limping. had it xrayed, yeh torn acl and whatever it is to the knee cap. the technical terms make my head dizzy. anyways, because of his weight and age the Vet strongly refused to do surgery. he said, it will just re rupture before it heals. he did not like the wrap type braces, so i went with the expensive hard hinge type, we just got it today custom made from a cast. it looks hideous and weighs allot. no way he can wear that thing around the house, how can he possibly sit or lay down? must be only if I take him out. for now I been using a dolly cart to get him from his beds to a door to go out to potty, I can lift him, but i cannot carry him. he weighs 60 pounds. his limp is awful. we keep him doped up on tramadol. rimadyl makes him ill, we cannot use it. I have to hand feed him and bring him his water several times a day. he can barely crouch to have a bowel movement. I am so sad. the vet said in a year, he will rupture his other leg. you would think with all the hiking we do his muscles would be strong, I don’t understand how this could happen. the Vet said nothing will fix him, he will never be “fixed”..I think he was hinting about putting him down. after we won the battle over cancer and he was feeling so perky, I just did not have the heart. so now I am by his side all day and night, he has about 6 beds around the house to switch from. as he gets tired laying in one all day. anything beter than Tramadol for pain for him? I know when the other side goes… I will have to make a decision. I already spent thousands on his cancer surgeries. even if I found a Vet who would, after paying $700 for this ridiculous brace, I am broke. anyone else used these had tamarrak hinged braces? is he right about his leg? and to refuse surgery? I heard surgery is very painful even more than the injury, I am thinking what do they call it pallative care, heavy pain meds till he has become so depressed then we will have to do something. I heard different stories, one says it could heal in 3-4 months and others say it will never HEAL it has to be reattached. who is right? do these braces really help? or will it cause insult to injury? and what about stronger pain med suggestions? he gets so bored, as he used to be an active dog and tries to wander and probably making it worse, I need to sedate him more. he is already taking 1 50mg every 8 hours. suggestions appreciated. just not FAIR..and confusing. exp to see a VET so against helping my dog, esp after we battled cancer…and won. I am in tears!

  15. Nancy says:

    My 7 1/2 year old lab is having knee surgery on her acl. Do you have any advice for her recovery. She will stay inside and be walked 3 times a day to go to bathroom. No furniture to climb on. What else should I know about.

  16. Kim says:

    Heidi thank you so much for your post. We rescued a german shepherd/Belgium mix. At 5 months old he thought he’d test out his puppy flying skills. He landed funny and tore his ACL. I have been hem-hawing on what to do (bones still growing type of thing as you described). But after reading your post I feel much better about waiting till he is done growing before getting the surgery (we are doing same one as your puppers did). We do only only one more hurdle than you….we have another dog who loves to play with his new puppy friend. That part has been the worst. Telling my boys they can’t play. Hopefully his surgery will go as well as your baby’s did. Thanks again.

  17. MC says:

    We are just now in the throws of dealing with a possible diagnosis and recommendation for surgery. We meet with the orthopedist later today. My biggest concern beyond the cost (!) is rehabilitation. Our home is not accessible without going up one flight of stairs. Any thoughts or ideas on how to manage getting recuperating large dogs up and down stairs during recovery? Thanks!

  18. tina says:

    My 12 year old yorkie , who is very active and in great shape. Has torn her ligament or so it seems on her left leg. She has degenerative joint diseases on her right leg and on her spine. She has had acupuncture treatment before and her Dr suggested to sedate her to get a detailed XRAY of her knee. We are going in tomorrow morning for this scan. I find your experience very helpful and will appreciate any advice you may be able to give me. I don’t know if I should take her to and orthopedic specialist for surgery or stick to the acupuncture ? Thanks

  19. Teresa says:

    My 9 year old Boxer tore her ACL a few days ago. She’s on pain meds and antiinflammatories. She also has severe arthritis in both hips and knees. I don’t want her to have surgery due to her age; she’s doing well on the meds. Would it be beneficial to wrap her leg to give it some stability when she has to walk on it?

  20. Rae says:

    I have a 12 year old PeekaPoo who had been limping for about 1 1/2 weeks. When taken to the vet I found out he had a torn ACL. The vet did not pressure me into any surgery. He gave me the option of surgery or pain pills to keep him comfortable. Most everyone I know that has had the surgery has told me because of his age and because he is small, they would not have the surgery done. But I don’t know if I can stand to watch him limp around the house. He was a very active dog and it just breaks my heart. I have decided to wait 2 wks. and see how he is doing and go from there.

  21. Heidi says:

    My Lucy is a lab/boxer mix. She is now just a few months shy of 2 years old. When she was 5 months old, she became lame, rear left leg. I thought rest would help and she was due to be spayed. 2 weeks of rest didn’t help so I had her evaluated. Xrays were taken and she failed the drawer test. Because of her age, I was referred to a University Teaching Vet Clinic. More xrays and again failed the drawer test.
    Because of she was so young, surgery wasn’t an option because her growth plates weren’t closed. It was recommended that I proceed with conservative management. I felt overwhelmed. How was I going to get thru the next 7-9 months? I had a 5 month old lab puppy that needed to not run or jump or be on any sort of slippery surfaces. I look back on how I managed and I have to say that it’s a miracle!

    First I bought 2 42″ high exercise pens and made my living room into an 8’x 8′ space, with an attached XL kennel. Save place to be all day and not be confined to a kennel. Checkmark!
    Second, her boredom levels skyrocketed and she started eating all her toys, even the ones I thought were chew proof. The search was on for safe objects to leave in her ex-pen while I wasn’t there to supervise. I found white shin bones stuffed with good stuff. I also found hollow white shin bones…that I stuffed and froze with various treats/kibble. I found treat balls, the egg one and the double ball one worked the best. I filled those with her kibble as well, with a few treats to make her think there might be more. I froze kongs filled with kibble and sealed with cream cheese or peanut butter, until started eating those. Elk antler was safe, as was a stainless steel water bowl. (she chewed the plastic one up) Items to occupy her daytime boredom and eliminate the need to check poop. Checkmark!
    Third. I need to make sure she didn’t run puppy races in the house. Baby gates to the rescue. It took 3 of them to close off rooms so I could limit how much of a run she could get. I got it down to about 8′. No running! Checkmark!
    Fourth. I needed to eliminate any slippery surfaces in my home. Arg! My entire kitchen floor is ceramic tile..:( Soo..I bought carpet runners that come on a roll and are cut to length at a local hardware store.
    I measured my kitchen and got rolls cut to length and laid them out. My white ceramic tile turned into grey carpet! I now got to vacuum my kitchen floor instead of wash it. No slippery surfaces. Checkmark!
    Fifth. Exercise she could do. I did daily walks with her, but did them in a local cemetery. It was quiet there. I put her on a field lead so she could have more freedom and let her wander. She loved it and I liked there was no pulling or tugging at her leash. I also found an indoor, above ground pool, for dogs. I took her swimming 1-2 times a week. She loved and still loves to go swimming. Go figure, a lab that likes swimming!
    Sixth. Social time. Before her injury, she went to doggie daycare. She loves other dogs. That had to stop. So in place of that, I found a local kennel, that would do daytime boarding, a couple times a week.
    That gave her some exposure to other dogs, but she never got to play with them. It also provided some socialization for her. I also took her everywhere I could. I took her to stores that allowed pets, pet fairs and garden centers. I also took her for rides. I started her in a medium carry kennel, she now has an xl one, we call it her box. Provide socialization. Checkmark!

    Lucy remained on leash, outside of my home, from the time she was 5 months old, until 8 weeks after her surgery, approximately 1 year.
    I opted for the Tightrope surgery for her. She had it done in late 12/2013. The vet commented what good shape she was in. Her bad leg had good muscle tone. Her coat is glossy from all the supplements I give her. Her weight is optimal, at about 70 pounds. I weigh her food portions to make sure she’s getting exactly what she needs. Her treats are all wholesome, with an ingredient list you can pronounce.

    So it was about middle of March, 2014, Lucy got to go pee and poop without someone standing over her and watching! Yah!

    She healed nicely, with no complications. She’s spoiled rotten, sweet as can be, obedient to hand commands and words. She’s learned to bark, but still doesn’t like to do stairs. She loves bully braids and asparagus and salmon. She won’t eat strawberries but loves blueberries.

    Her left foot was smaller than her right, but now, almost 6 months post surgery, you can barely see the difference. She does have a skip in her step. The vet and I discussed and think she may always have that. She was so young when this all happened, it just might be the way she learned to run.

    It’s been a long journey. I truly didn’t sign up for level of care she needed. But I also couldn’t ask someone else to take on the responsibility of a special needs dog.

    I still don’t let her run and get crazy with other dogs. I don’t have enough control over her puppy brain to interrupt her instincts to play or chase.
    I’d like to think her other knee won’t have issues. I’m more realistic than that. I have a savings account going for her next knee surgery. If it never happens, bonus! I get to go on a well needed vacation!

    People ask me, when they see us together, how I got such a well behaved Lab. I smile and just say what a special girl she is.

Leave a Reply